Chapter 11: What Would You Do?
Elin, a forty-five-year-old female, has been brought to the outpatient mental health clinic by her family. She has a history of severe alcohol use disorder and has been involved in multiple legal incidents related to her substance misuse. These incidents range from driving under the influence (DUI) charges to public intoxication and altercations related to her aggressive behavior. Family members have expressed great concern about her safety as well as the safety of others, highlighting the urgency of a comprehensive intervention. She presents with symptoms of anxiety, depression, and occasional episodes of aggression. Elin’s medical history includes chronic liver disease due to her alcohol consumption. She has previously engaged in outpatient treatment for substance misuse, but has struggled to maintain sobriety.
1. Considering Elin’s history of legal incidents and the potential threat to her own safety and others, discuss why court-ordered therapy might be deemed necessary for her case. How do the legal implications of her substance misuse contribute to the decision for involuntary intervention, and, what ethical considerations should be taken into account?
2. Given Elin’s complex needs, provide examples of specific types of court-ordered therapy that could be beneficial in her case. How might inpatient rehabilitation, dual diagnosis treatment, and counseling programs address the multifaceted challenges presented by her severe alcohol use disorder, chronic liver disease, and co-occurring anxiety and depression?
3. What legal criteria and procedures would need to be considered when initiating involuntary court-ordered treatment for Elin? Identify and discuss the steps involved in determining whether she meets the necessary criteria for involuntary intervention.
4. Identify three specific mental health issues that Alexandra is currently facing based on her reported symptoms and history. How do these issues contribute to concerns regarding her safety in the emergency department?
5. Outline at least three immediate approaches nurses can employ in the ED to address Alexandra’s safety concerns based on her elevated vital signs and agitated state. How can the physical environment and communication strategies contribute to ensuring her safety during this encounter?
6. Considering Alexandra’s case, what specific challenges might nurses face in ensuring their own safety while providing care? How can interdisciplinary collaboration and clear communication contribute to enhancing staff safety in the context of this emergency situation?
7. Sunil’s psychiatric history includes multiple hospitalizations due to manic episodes. How might the power of attorney designated to his sister play a crucial role in ensuring continuity of care during his hospitalizations? Discuss specific scenarios where the sister’s involvement might be essential.
8. Sunil has a living will specifying treatment preferences during periods of incapacitation. How can the nurse effectively communicate and collaborate with Sunil’s sister to tailor his care to his preferences while balancing the legal and ethical aspects of mental health nursing?
9. Define the role of psychiatric advance directives in mental health care. How might Sunil’s psychiatric advance directive influence decision-making in specific psychiatric interventions, and what challenges could arise in implementing these directives within the clinical setting?
10. Given Geraldine’s advanced Alzheimer’s disease and cognitive decline, how would you define the role of a guardian or conservator in her situation? Consider the specific responsibilities and decision-making authority that a guardian or conservator might have in managing her health care and living arrangements.
11. Outline the step-by-step process for appointing a guardian or conservator for Geraldine, taking into account her advanced Alzheimer’s disease. Consider the legal and procedural aspects involved in initiating and completing this process.
12. In Geraldine’s case, how might the appointment of a guardian or conservator impact her overall well-being, considering not only medical decisions but also aspects of her daily life and personal preferences? Discuss potential benefits and drawbacks of such an appointment.